Smart Web 2.0 referencing

How to prevent link rot of Internet references in blogs and other publications?

Link decay
In recent years, there has been an increase in electronic references in scholarly literature, distance learning resources, and other documents. This has been accompanied by a dramatic rise in link rot. While threatening the foundations of academic research, it is also annoying to the average Internet user and devalues the effort put in the publication. But there is a way around the problem of unstable links, which may also help you in your work, research, or studies in a number of other ways.

A possible solution
Instead of referring directly to URLs on the Internet, you could refer to documents in your own online reference manager. Provided you don´t change these intermediary URLs yourself, they remain stable. In itself this does not prevent link rot. There is a continued need to check the links in the reference manager and repair any broken links. This is usually no problem. The advantage is that maintenance can be done centrally and systematically. You could even use free link checking software to do most of the work.

Does it work?
I conducted a practical test using a post on social network analysis in my CSL4D blog. The post contains about 10 citations. Most of these provide a link to a reference in Mendeley, my free reference manager. From there, a link is provided to the actual online document or web page (follow the “Available from …” link). If the link breaks, a new one can be added, but meanwhile visitors may be able to find the paper or book via Google Scholar or WorldCat. Direct links to these services are provided by Mendeley. It is good to know that if Google Scholar fails, it is usually worth making one more click to Google Web. If you have resources on the Internet, but in an environment that is controlled by yourself such as Scribd or DropBox, you have full control over the link. If you make a change there, you should not forget to make a corresponding change in Mendeley.

Are there other advantages?
The entire solution can be implemented using free Web 2.0 tools. The visibility of the right Web 2.0 tools can be very high, so it is also a way of mainstreaming your ideas. Generally, web 2.0 tools are very user-friendly. You can add to the user-friendliness of your blog or document by stopping link rot and facilitate the import of metadata for your carefully selected references.

Relevance to international development
Many publications by international development institutions such as the CGIAR centres, the OECD, or the World Bank, and by the multitude of smaller development organizations are not cited in scholarly databases, because they are published without the involvement of academic publishers. The advantage is that the documents are free, which is important for audiences in the Global South. The drawback is that these documents are more difficult to find by systematic searches. Their findability improves by referring to them in free, online reference managers, such as Mendeley. An alternative to Mendeley is Zotero. I use Zotero My Library to collect material and export a selection of key references, i.e. metadata and links, to Mendeley. This may sounds strange, but it works well for me. At least for now ;-).

A final note
To some the proposed method will no doubt sound a bit cumbersome. Yet, it could appeal to many of those working in research project and higher education settings. Students may use blog posts to keep track of progress during assignments. This allows teaching staff to monitor and assist them. The combination with a reference manager and other web 2.0 tools makes it all the more valuable.

This post was generated using Joe Novak´s Cmap Tools and applying the main principles of Bob Horn´s structured writing.

P.S. Update 31/12/2012: An alternative method involves the use of webcitation.org, see e.g. this reference in one of my Mendeley groups.

Advertisements

About Sjon van ’t Hof

Development professional who worked in rural development, tropical agriculture, and irrigation development in Chad, Zambia, Mali, Ghana, Mauritania, Israel, Burkina Faso, Niger, and the Netherlands in capacities ranging from project design and management to information management. Conducted missions to India, China, Kenya, and Bangladesh. Experience in the development and delivery of trainings in irrigation equipment selection, information literacy, Internet searching and database searching. Explores systems thinking in relation to international development, education, and management, with an ever stronger focus on the systems approach of C. West Churchman. Knowledgeable in tropical agriculture, project design and development economics, agricultural mechanization, irrigation, plant pathology, environmental degradation and protection, rural development. Co-authored "Wicked Solutions: a systems approach to complex problems", a book written by Bob Williams and Sjon van 't Hof. It was published in June 2014 and provides a practical way of dealing with wicked problems. Wicked problems are complex, ill-structured, human problem situations. This book will help you design an inquiry and intervention in such messy, wicked situations. It does so by guiding you through the steps and stages of a systemic process that addresses your own wicked problem. For more information, see https://csl4d.wordpress.com/ or http://www.bobwilliams.co.nz/Systems_Resources.html
This entry was posted in General, Meaningful learning. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Smart Web 2.0 referencing

  1. Bernadine says:

    This design is incredible! You obviously know how to keep a reader entertained.
    Between your wit and your videos, I was almost moved
    to start my own blog (well, almost…HaHa!) Excellent job.
    I really loved what you had to say, and more than that, how
    you presented it. Too cool!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s